Car insurance is a necessity for drivers across the USA, but costs can vary dramatically depending on where you live, your driving record, and the insurer you choose. In 2025, with the average full coverage car insurance premium at $2,667 annually (or $222/month) and liability-only at $807 ($67/month), per CNBC Select (2025), finding affordable coverage is more critical than ever. At InsureGenz, we’re dedicated to helping you save money while securing reliable protection.
This state-by-state guide identifies the cheapest car insurance companies in the USA for 2025, based on recent data, and offers practical tips to lower your premiums. Whether you’re a young driver, a senior, or someone with a less-than-perfect driving record, this guide will help you find the best rates in your state.
Why Car Insurance Rates Vary by State in 2025
Car insurance premiums are influenced by state-specific factors, including:
-
Regulations: Each state sets its own minimum coverage requirements, affecting costs. For example, California doubled bodily injury and tripled property damage liability requirements in 2025, driving up premiums by 17%, per Kiplinger (2025).
-
Risk Factors: States with higher rates of accidents, theft, or natural disasters (e.g., hurricanes in Florida) have higher premiums. Louisiana has the highest average full coverage rate at $2,883/year, while Maine’s is the lowest at $949/year, per U.S. News (2025).
-
Population Density: Urban states like New York have higher rates due to congestion and claims, while rural states like Vermont benefit from lower risk.
-
Credit Usage: States like California, Hawaii, and Massachusetts ban credit-based insurance scores, potentially lowering rates for drivers with poor credit.
To find the cheapest car insurance, compare quotes from multiple providers, as rates vary based on your age, driving history, credit score (where allowed), and vehicle type. Use InsureGenz’s quote comparison tool to get started.
Cheapest Car Insurance Companies by State in 2025
Below is a state-by-state guide to the cheapest car insurance companies for full coverage, based on data from Forbes (2025), U.S. News (2025), The Zebra (2025), and Bankrate (2025). Rates are averages for a 40-year-old driver with a clean record, good credit, and a 2025 Toyota Camry, with 100/300/100 liability, uninsured motorist coverage, and collision/comprehensive with a $500 deductible, unless otherwise noted. Note: USAA is often the cheapest but is only available to military members, veterans, and their families, so the next cheapest option is listed for broader accessibility.
-
Alabama: Auto-Owners ($1,200/year). Competitive rates and strong customer satisfaction, available in 26 states.
-
Alaska: Geico ($1,150/year). Offers low rates and 16 discounts, including multi-vehicle and good driver.
-
Arizona: Travelers ($1,300/year). Affordable full coverage with telematics discounts via IntelliDrive.
-
Arkansas: State Farm ($1,250/year). Cheapest in 21 states, with Drive Safe & Save for safe drivers.
-
California: Geico ($1,400/year). Competitive despite new liability requirements; credit scores not used.
-
Colorado: American National ($1,350/year). Low rates for various driver profiles, including teens and DUIs.
-
Connecticut: Geico ($1,500/year). Strong digital experience and discounts for safe drivers.
-
Delaware: Travelers ($1,450/year). Offers gap insurance and accident forgiveness.
-
Florida: Geico ($2,200/year). High rates due to hurricanes; compare quotes to save.
-
Georgia: Auto-Owners ($1,300/year). Affordable and available in 26 states.
-
Hawaii: Geico ($862/year). Cheapest in the nation; credit scores not used.
-
Idaho: State Farm ($780/year). Lowest rates in a low-risk, rural state.
-
Illinois: Travelers ($1,200/year). Strong customer feedback and telematics savings.
-
Indiana: Geico ($877/year). Competitive rates and easy online quoting.
-
Iowa: State Farm ($780/year). Affordable with high customer satisfaction.
-
Kansas: Farm Bureau ($1,100/year). Low liability-only rates at $53/month.
-
Kentucky: Geico ($1,350/year). Offers discounts for bundling and good students.
-
Louisiana: Southern Farm Bureau ($2,100/year). High rates due to severe weather; compare quotes.
-
Maine: Auto-Owners ($620/year). Cheapest in the nation for full coverage.
-
Maryland: Geico ($1,200/year). Rates dropped 20% from 2022–2025; credit scores not used.
-
Massachusetts: State Farm ($1,100/year). Credit scores banned, benefiting poor-credit drivers.
-
Michigan: Travelers ($1,800/year). Rates rose 29% from 2022–2025 due to urban risks.
-
Minnesota: American National ($1,050/year). Low rates for drivers with accidents or DUIs.
-
Mississippi: Travelers ($1,300/year). Competitive with rideshare and gap insurance options.
-
Missouri: State Farm ($1,150/year). Affordable with strong J.D. Power satisfaction scores.
-
Montana: Progressive ($1,100/year). Offers accident forgiveness and online discounts.
-
Nebraska: Farm Bureau ($1,050/year). Strong for liability-only at $53/month.
-
Nevada: Geico ($1,450/year). Competitive in high-risk urban areas.
-
New Hampshire: Auto-Owners ($900/year). No insurance mandate but low rates for full coverage.
-
New Jersey: Geico ($1,600/year). High rates due to urban density; compare quotes.
-
New Mexico: Farm Bureau ($1,100/year). Affordable liability and full coverage options.
-
New York: Progressive ($1,800/year). High rates due to urban risks; bundling saves up to 25%.
-
North Carolina: Erie ($950/year). Cheapest in 12 states but limited availability.
-
North Dakota: American National ($1,000/year). Low rates for various driver profiles.
-
Ohio: Erie ($900/year). Affordable in a low-cost state; limited to 12 states.
-
Oklahoma: State Farm ($1,200/year). Competitive with telematics discounts.
-
Oregon: State Farm ($1,100/year). Credit scores not used, benefiting poor-credit drivers.
-
Pennsylvania: Erie ($1,050/year). Gender not used for rates, ensuring fairness.
-
Rhode Island: Travelers ($1,600/year). Offers telematics and accident forgiveness.
-
South Carolina: American National ($1,150/year). Strong for teens and high-risk drivers.
-
South Dakota: Farm Bureau ($1,000/year). Low liability rates at $53/month.
-
Tennessee: Auto-Owners ($999/year). Competitive in a low-cost state.
-
Texas: State Farm ($1,300/year). Largest insurer with strong customer service.
-
Utah: Geico ($1,050/year). Credit scores not used, benefiting poor-credit drivers.
-
Vermont: State Farm ($800/year). Low rates in a rural, low-risk state.
-
Virginia: Erie ($950/year). Affordable but limited to 12 states.
-
Washington: Travelers ($1,200/year). 25% rate hike due to theft and repair costs.
-
West Virginia: Erie ($1,000/year). Competitive in a low-cost state.
-
Wisconsin: American National ($950/year). Low rates for various driver profiles.
-
Wyoming: Farm Bureau ($1,050/year). Affordable liability and full coverage.
-
Washington, D.C.: Geico ($1,200/year). Competitive despite urban risks.
Note: Rates are approximate and vary based on individual factors like age, driving record, and credit score (where allowed). Always compare quotes using InsureGenz for personalized rates.
Top Cheapest Car Insurance Companies Nationwide
Based on NerdWallet (2025), MoneyGeek (2025), and Bankrate (2025), the following insurers consistently offer low rates across multiple states and driver profiles:
-
USAA: Cheapest overall ($99/month full coverage, $50/month liability), but limited to military, veterans, and families. Offers discounts like 15% for on-base garaging.
-
Geico: Cheapest for liability ($43/month) and poor credit drivers ($1,200/year full coverage). Available in all 50 states with 16 discounts.
-
Travelers: Cheapest for full coverage ($122/month) and DUIs ($1,800/year). Offers IntelliDrive telematics for up to 30% savings.
-
State Farm: Cheapest in 21 states ($134/month full coverage). Strong for young drivers and telematics via Drive Safe & Save.
-
Auto-Owners: Low rates in 26 states ($1,200/year full coverage). Ideal for teens and high-risk drivers.
-
Erie: Cheapest in 12 states ($950/year full coverage). Strong for young drivers but limited availability.
-
American National: Competitive for teens, DUIs, and accidents ($1,050/year full coverage).
-
Farm Bureau: Cheapest liability ($53/month) in select states.
Tips to Save on Car Insurance in 2025
To secure the lowest rates, consider these strategies, per Forbes (2025) and The Zebra (2025):
-
Compare Quotes: Get quotes from at least three insurers using InsureGenz’s comparison tool. Rates can vary by thousands annually.
-
Leverage Discounts: Look for discounts like safe driver, good student, multi-car, bundling (up to 25% off), or autopay (up to 14% savings).
-
Maintain a Clean Record: Avoid accidents and tickets, as a single DUI can raise premiums by 96%, per Bankrate (2025).
-
Choose Usage-Based Insurance: Programs like USAA’s SafePilot, Travelers’ IntelliDrive, or Nationwide’s SmartMiles save up to 30% for safe or low-mileage drivers.
-
Increase Deductibles: A higher deductible (e.g., $1,000 vs. $500) lowers premiums but increases out-of-pocket costs.
-
Improve Credit: In states allowing credit-based scores, good credit can save 67% compared to poor credit.
-
Drive a Low-Risk Vehicle: Smaller SUVs like the Toyota RAV4 are cheaper to insure than sports cars.
-
Pay Annually: Avoid monthly fees and save up to 14% by paying upfront, per NerdWallet (2025).
Example: Saving with the Right Insurer
Consider Sarah, a 30-year-old in Maine with a clean record and good credit. She compares quotes and finds Auto-Owners at $620/year for full coverage, compared to the state average of $949. By bundling with her renters insurance and enrolling in a telematics program, she saves an additional 20%, reducing her premium to $496/year—a $453 annual saving.
Why Choose InsureGenz for Your Car Insurance Needs?
At InsureGenz, we simplify finding affordable car insurance in the USA, Canada, and UK. Our platform offers:
-
Free Quote Comparison: Compare rates from top insurers like Geico, Travelers, and State Farm in minutes.
-
Insurance Calculator: Estimate your coverage needs based on your state and profile.
-
Expert Resources: Explore guides on car insurance basics and saving on premiums.
FAQs About Cheap Car Insurance in the USA
Q: Which state has the cheapest car insurance in 2025?
A: Maine offers the lowest average full coverage rate at $949/year, followed by Idaho ($992) and Vermont ($1,237).
Q: Is USAA always the cheapest?
A: USAA is often the cheapest ($99/month full coverage), but it’s only available to military members, veterans, and their families. Geico and Travelers are competitive alternatives.
Q: How can I lower my premiums if I have a DUI?
A: Travelers offers the lowest rates for DUIs ($1,800/year). Compare quotes, complete a driver safety course, and maintain a clean record to reduce costs.
Q: Does credit score affect car insurance rates?
A: Yes, in most states. Poor credit can increase premiums by 67%. States like California, Hawaii, and Massachusetts ban credit-based scoring.
Q: Should I choose liability-only or full coverage?
A: Liability-only ($807/year average) is cheaper and meets state requirements, but full coverage ($2,667/year) protects your vehicle. Choose based on your car’s value and financial needs.
Conclusion
In 2025, finding the cheapest car insurance in the USA requires comparing quotes, leveraging discounts, and understanding state-specific factors. Whether you’re in low-cost Maine or high-cost Louisiana, insurers like Geico, Travelers, State Farm, and Auto-Owners offer competitive rates for various driver profiles. Use InsureGenz to compare quotes, explore telematics programs, and find the best coverage for your budget. Start saving today and drive with confidence knowing you’re protected at the lowest cost.
